LGBTData.comSexual orientation, gender identity and intersex data and measures

Defining and measuring sexual orientation: a history

This is a shortened version of Randall L. Sell's essay "Defining and Measuring Sexual Orientations for Research". Its argument: researchers should define what they mean by sexual orientation and say so, because identity, attraction and behavior don't line up neatly, and the measure follows from the definition.

Defining and Measuring Sexual Orientations for Research

Randall L. Sell

Why definitions matter

Researchers have long struggled to define populations such as those set apart by race and ethnicity, and to find methods that identify their members in practice (LaVeist, 2002). Now that sexual orientation is being treated as a demographic variable, the same scrutiny is owed to how it is defined and how it is measured.

When researchers study sexual orientation, they often seem unsure what they are studying (Shively et al., 1985; Sell and Petrulio, 1996; Chung and Katayama, 1996). Reviews find that conceptual definitions are rarely stated in research reports, that they differ when they are stated, and that the measures used often do not match the definitions. Sell and Petrulio called for uniform definitions and agreed-upon methods of measurement, echoing Henry (1955), who warned that "unless the word homosexual is clearly defined, objective discussion regarding it is futile."

The problem is not only one of words. Identity, attraction and behavior do not line up neatly, so a study that defines sexual orientation by one of them will find a different population from a study that uses another. This essay reviews the definitions and measures used since the 1860s, when Karl Heinrich Ulrichs began the formal study of sexual orientation, to encourage researchers to choose deliberately, and say plainly, how they identify and label the people they study.

Early definitions, 1860s to 1950s

Ulrichs. In pamphlets he published himself in the 1860s, Ulrichs proposed one of the earliest and most influential classification schemes (Ulrichs, 1994). It was written for men, whom he sorted into "dionings," "urnings" and "uranodionings," names drawn from Pausanias's speech about Uranus in Plato's Symposium. His categories correspond roughly to today's heterosexual, gay and bisexual. He called women "urningins" and "dioningins" (Bullough, 1990). Ulrichs shaped the writers who followed him, among them Krafft-Ebing, Ellis and Hirschfeld, and through them, Bullough (1994) argues, Freud and Jung. Most of the conceptions of sexual orientation cited today trace back to him, even where they depart from him.

Benkert. Ulrichs disliked the words "homosexual" and "heterosexual," yet they first appear in a letter written to him on May 6, 1868, by the German-Hungarian writer Karl Maria Benkert (Ulrichs, 1994). In an 1869 pamphlet Benkert defined homosexuality as an innate "homosexual urge" that left those affected averse to the other sex (Robinson, 1936). The word mixes Greek and Latin roots, and early researchers wanted to replace it, but it was already too entrenched (Kinsey et al., 1948).

Ellis. Havelock Ellis, the leading English writer on sexuality at the turn of the twentieth century, also defined the phenomenon purely as a psychological state: a "sexual instinct turned by inborn constitutional abnormality toward persons of the same sex" (Ellis and Symonds, 1896). He first called this "sexual inversion" and later adopted "homosexuality" (Ellis, 1942).

Krafft-Ebing. Richard von Krafft-Ebing (1886) went further and excluded behavior from the diagnosis altogether. What counted, in his view, was the presence of "perverse feelings" toward the same sex, not proof of sexual acts with someone of the same sex.

Forel. Auguste Forel (1924) likewise located homosexuality in the sexual appetite and its psychic extensions, directed toward the same sex. Behavior entered his definition only negatively, as horror at genital contact with the other sex. This was typical of early definitions: when behavior appears at all, it is as the repugnance of sex with the other sex.

Beach. At the opposite pole stands Frank Beach (1950), who, commenting on the first English translation of André Gide's Corydon, insisted that homosexuality "refers exclusively to overt behavior between two individuals of the same sex," involving erotic arousal and usually satisfaction of the sexual urge. Psychological states play no part.

Psychological and behavioral components

Most definitions contain a psychological component, a behavioral component, or both, and how the two are joined matters. LeVay (1993) defines sexual orientation as "the direction of sexual feelings or behavior," and Weinrich (1994) defines homosexuality as either a genital act or a long-term sexuoerotic status. Because they use "or," either component alone is enough to classify someone. Francoeur et al. (1991) instead define homosexuality as sexual attraction, interest and genitally intimate activity with members of the same gender, which leaves unclear whether a person must show all of them. Some definitions use behavior only. Stedman's Medical Dictionary (1982) defines homosexuality as sexual behavior between individuals of the same sex, as Beach did, and this is the approach favored by researchers estimating the size of gay populations: none of the studies Diamond (1993) reviewed assessed attraction, though all assessed sexual behavior.

So far I have discussed these two components as if each were uniform, but they are not. The psychological component goes by many names: sexual passion, urge, feelings, attraction, interest, arousal, desire, affectional preference, sexual instinct, sexual orientation identity and sexual preference. Each may describe a slightly different phenomenon under a shared label. One term deserves to be dropped. Gonsiorek and Weinrich (1991) argue that "sexual preference" is misleading because it assumes conscious or deliberate choice and trivializes processes that are a basic part of the psyche and form long before anything like a choice could be made. "Sexual orientation" is the better term, and it is the one used here.

The behavioral component varies just as much: "sexual behavior," genital activity, sexual intercourse, sexual contact, or sexual contact resulting in orgasm. Each must itself be defined and then made measurable.

No review can show that one definition is better than another, but two modest recommendations follow. Researchers who plan to collect data on sexual orientation should choose one of these definitions, or develop their own, before the research begins. And when they present their studies, they should state explicitly which terms and definitions they used. The measure should follow from that definition, not the other way round.

Measures

Measures of sexual orientation vary as widely as definitions. The earliest records of assessment come from confession manuals of the Western Church. In 1595 the missionary Francisco de Pareja wrote questions for his Confessionario to identify "sodomites" among the Timucua of Florida, asking men whether they had had intercourse with another man (Katz, 1992). In the 1860s Ulrichs proposed questions to determine whether a man was an "urning," such as whether he was passionately attracted only to men and whether sexual contact with women horrified him (Ulrichs, 1994). Respondents answered yes or no and were classified accordingly. That simple categorical approach still dominates: people are classified as gay or heterosexual by identity or by behavior (Sell and Petrulio, 1996). For major health surveys, Miller (2002) recommended a single identity question with four answers: straight or heterosexual; gay or lesbian; bisexual; don't know or not sure. Over the past half-century, though, researchers have proposed more sophisticated measures as the limits of simple categories became clear.

The Kinsey Scale. The most influential is the seven-point scale of Kinsey et al. (1948, 1953), running from exclusively heterosexual to exclusively homosexual. Kinsey rejected dichotomies: "The world is not to be divided into sheep and goats," and "only the human mind invents categories and tries to force facts into separated pigeon-holes." It is ironic that this came from a man trained as a taxonomist (Weinrich, 1990). The scale has three weaknesses.

First, it is hard to weigh a person's heterosexual and homosexual experience against each other. Masters and Johnson (1979) found ratings of 2 to 4 difficult to assign to people with extensive experience of both, and a rating of 3 the hardest of all.

Second, it lumps together people who differ on separate dimensions of sexuality (Weinrich et al., 1993; Weinberg et al., 1994). Kinsey based ratings on both "overt sexual experience" and "psychosexual reactions," which do not always agree, and collapsing them into one score throws away information. A common remedy is to rate dimensions separately, most often behavior and fantasy. Klein et al. (1985) went further: the Klein Sexual Orientation Grid assesses seven dimensions, though every dimension added makes a measure more burdensome. Few studies have tested whether the dimensions differ. A factor analysis of the Klein Grid found that its items largely measured a single construct, with a second factor of social and emotional preference that may measure something other than sexual orientation (Weinrich et al., 1993). Yet the dimensions clearly identify different people. In the National Health and Social Life Survey (Laumann et al., 1994), of the 8.6% of women who reported some same-sex sexuality, 88% reported same-sex desire, 41% same-sex behavior and 16% a lesbian or gay identity; of the 10.1% of men, 75% reported desire, 52% behavior and 27% a gay identity. In a Houston street-outreach sample, Ross et al. (2003) found that identity and behavior often disagreed, and concluded that HIV-risk interventions and clinical screening should be based on behavior rather than identity.

Third, the scale treats homosexuality and heterosexuality as opposite ends of one continuum, so more of one means less of the other. Bem (1981) showed that masculinity and femininity are better measured separately, allowing people to be high or low on both, and the same may hold here. Bullough (1990) judged that the Kinsey Scale had outlived its political usefulness.

Shively and DeCecco. Shively and DeCecco (1977) proposed measuring heterosexuality and homosexuality independently, each on a five-point scale, for both physical and affectional preference.

Storms. Storms (1980) measured same-sex and other-sex fantasies on separate scales. Bisexual participants reported as many same-sex fantasies as gay participants and as many other-sex fantasies as heterosexual participants, which led him to conclude that the two should be measured independently, at least for fantasy.

The Sell Assessment. The Sell Assessment of Sexual Orientation was designed to answer all three concerns: it measures sexual orientation on continua, across several dimensions, and with heterosexuality and homosexuality assessed separately (Gonsiorek et al., 1995; Sell, 1996). It defines sexual orientation as the extent of sexual attraction toward members of the other sex, the same sex, both sexes or neither, so its six attraction questions carry the most weight; four questions on behavior and two on identity add supplementary information. Behavior usually reflects attraction, and identity should, but social and cultural pressures can pull them apart, and which matters most depends on the study. HIV research, for example, might use attraction to define the population, behavior to find those at greatest risk, and identity to target prevention. The full profile is more than many researchers need, so four summary scoring methods are offered. The measure is meant to provoke debate rather than settle it; Friedman et al. (2004), for example, are building on it to develop a measure for adolescents.

Choosing a measure

Researchers increasingly need a sexual orientation variable. The problems of measuring race and ethnicity have been widely debated; for sexual orientation that work has barely begun, and definitive recommendations of one measure over another cannot yet be made. More research is needed (Solarz, 1999; Gay and Lesbian Medical Association, 2001).

The tools available are simple categorical questions (Miller, 2002), the Kinsey Scale (Kinsey et al., 1948), the Klein Grid (Klein et al., 1985), the Shively and DeCecco scale (Shively and DeCecco, 1977), the Sell Assessment (Sell, 1996) and the Friedman measure for adolescents (Friedman et al., 2004). None is fully satisfactory. Categorical questions fall short for the reasons Kinsey gave, and their reliability and validity have seldom been tested thoroughly. The Kinsey Scale artificially combines psychological and behavioral components and forces a trade-off between heterosexuality and homosexuality. The importance of each Klein dimension has not been established empirically or theoretically, and the Klein Grid shares Kinsey's trade-off. The Shively and DeCecco scale has not been thoroughly investigated, and its split between physical and affectional preference may be too simple. The Sell Assessment and the Friedman measure rest on current theory but are largely untested, and may be too burdensome for typical studies.

The problems are sharpest in the many studies that have room for only one question. Whatever the measure, the rule is the same: decide first what you mean by sexual orientation, choose the measure that captures that meaning, and tell your readers both. For current advice on which questions to use, see the Recommend page on this site.

References

Beach, F. A. (1950). Comments on the second dialogue. In A. Gide, Corydon. New York: Farrar, Straus.

Bem, S. L. (1981). Bem Sex-Role Inventory: Professional Manual. Palo Alto, CA: Consulting Psychologists Press.

Bullough, V. L. (1990). The Kinsey Scale in historical perspective. In D. P. McWhirter, S. A. Sanders and J. M. Reinisch (Eds.), Homosexuality/Heterosexuality: Concepts of Sexual Orientation. New York: Oxford University Press.

Bullough, V. L. (1994). Introduction. In K. H. Ulrichs, The Riddle of "Man-Manly" Love. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books.

Chung, Y. B., and Katayama, M. (1996). Assessment of sexual orientation in lesbian/gay/bisexual studies. Journal of Homosexuality, 30(4), 49–62. https://doi.org/10.1300/J082v30n04_03

Diamond, M. (1993). Homosexuality and bisexuality in different populations. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 22(4), 291–310. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01542119

Ellis, H. (1942). Studies in the Psychology of Sex. New York: Random House.

Ellis, H., and Symonds, J. A. (1896). Sexual Inversion. London: Wilson and Macmillan.

Forel, A. (1924). The Sexual Question: A Scientific, Psychological, Hygienic and Sociological Study. New York: Physicians and Surgeons Book Company.

Francoeur, R. T., Perper, T., and Scherzer, N. A. (Eds.) (1991). A Descriptive Dictionary and Atlas of Sexology. New York: Greenwood Press.

Friedman, M. S., Silvestre, A. J., Gold, M. A., Markovic, N., Savin-Williams, R. C., Huggins, J., and Sell, R. L. (2004). Adolescents define sexual orientation and suggest ways to measure it. Journal of Adolescence, 27(3), 303–317. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.adolescence.2004.03.006

Gay and Lesbian Medical Association and LGBT health experts (2001). Healthy People 2010 Companion Document for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) Health. San Francisco, CA: Gay and Lesbian Medical Association.

Gonsiorek, J. C., Sell, R. L., and Weinrich, J. D. (1995). Definition and measurement of sexual orientation. Suicide and Life-Threatening Behavior, 25(Suppl.), 40–51.

Gonsiorek, J. C., and Weinrich, J. D. (1991). The definition and scope of sexual orientation. In J. C. Gonsiorek and J. D. Weinrich (Eds.), Homosexuality: Research Implications for Public Policy. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

Henry, G. W. (1955). All the Sexes: A Study of Masculinity and Femininity. New York: Rinehart.

Katz, J. N. (1992). Gay American History: Lesbians and Gay Men in the U.S.A. (Rev. ed.). New York: Meridian.

Kinsey, A. C., Pomeroy, W. B., and Martin, C. E. (1948). Sexual Behavior in the Human Male. Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders.

Kinsey, A. C., Pomeroy, W. B., Martin, C. E., and Gebhard, P. H. (1953). Sexual Behavior in the Human Female. Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Saunders.

Klein, F., Sepekoff, B., and Wolf, T. J. (1985). Sexual orientation: A multi-variable dynamic process. Journal of Homosexuality, 11(1–2), 35–49. https://doi.org/10.1300/J082v11n01_04

Krafft-Ebing, R. von (1886). Psychopathia Sexualis: Eine klinisch-forensische Studie. Stuttgart: Enke.

Laumann, E. O., Gagnon, J. H., Michael, R. T., and Michaels, S. (1994). The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

LaVeist, T. A. (2002). Beyond dummy variables and sample selection: What health services researchers ought to know about race as a variable. In T. A. LaVeist (Ed.), Race, Ethnicity, and Health: A Public Health Reader. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

LeVay, S. (1993). The Sexual Brain. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Masters, W. H., and Johnson, V. E. (1979). Homosexuality in Perspective. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.

Miller, K. (2002). Cognitive Analysis of Sexual Identity, Attraction and Behavior Questions. Working Paper No. 32. Hyattsville, MD: National Center for Health Statistics.

Robinson, V. (Ed.) (1936). Encyclopaedia Sexualis. New York: Dingwall-Rock.

Ross, M. W., Essien, E. J., Williams, M. L., and Fernandez-Esquer, M. E. (2003). Concordance between sexual behavior and sexual identity in street outreach samples of four racial/ethnic groups. Sexually Transmitted Diseases, 30(2), 110–113. https://doi.org/10.1097/00007435-200302000-00003

Sell, R. L. (1996). The Sell Assessment of Sexual Orientation: Background and scoring. Journal of Gay, Lesbian, and Bisexual Identity, 1(4), 295–310. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03372244

Sell, R. L., and Petrulio, C. (1996). Sampling homosexuals, bisexuals, gays, and lesbians for public health research: A review of the literature from 1990 to 1992. Journal of Homosexuality, 30(4), 31–47. https://doi.org/10.1300/J082v30n04_02

Shively, M. G., and DeCecco, J. P. (1977). Components of sexual identity. Journal of Homosexuality, 3(1), 41–48. https://doi.org/10.1300/J082v03n01_04

Shively, M. G., Jones, C., and DeCecco, J. P. (1985). Research on sexual orientation: Definitions and methods. In J. P. DeCecco and M. G. Shively (Eds.), Origins of Sexuality and Homosexuality. New York: Harrington Park Press.

Solarz, A. L. (Ed.) (1999). Lesbian Health: Current Assessment and Directions for the Future. Institute of Medicine. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.

Stedman's Medical Dictionary (1982). Baltimore, MD: Williams and Wilkins.

Storms, M. D. (1980). Theories of sexual orientation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 38(5), 783–792.

Ulrichs, K. H. (1994). The Riddle of "Man-Manly" Love (M. A. Lombardi-Nash, Trans.). Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books.

Weinberg, M. S., Williams, C. J., and Pryor, D. W. (1994). Dual Attraction: Understanding Bisexuality. New York: Oxford University Press.

Weinrich, J. D. (1990). The Kinsey Scale in biology, with a note on Kinsey as a biologist. In D. P. McWhirter, S. A. Sanders and J. M. Reinisch (Eds.), Homosexuality/Heterosexuality: Concepts of Sexual Orientation. New York: Oxford University Press.

Weinrich, J. D. (1994). Homosexuality. In V. L. Bullough and B. Bullough (Eds.), Human Sexuality: An Encyclopedia. New York: Garland.

Weinrich, J. D., Snyder, P. J., Pillard, R. C., Grant, I., Jacobson, D. L., Robinson, S. R., and McCutchan, J. A. (1993). A factor analysis of the Klein Sexual Orientation Grid in two disparate samples. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 22(2), 157–168. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01542364

Postscript, 2026

Since this essay was written, the field has moved from choosing among research scales to agreeing on standard survey items. The Institute of Medicine's 2011 report on LGBT health called for sexual orientation and gender identity questions in federal surveys. The National Health Interview Survey added sexual orientation in 2013, and many states adopted an optional BRFSS module from 2014. In 2022 the National Academies recommended standard questions on sex, gender identity, sexual orientation and intersex status, and in 2023 the Office of Management and Budget issued best practices for federal surveys. In 2025, many federal surveys removed gender identity questions, and some changed sexual orientation items. The case this essay makes, that researchers should define their terms and choose measures to fit, applies to gender identity as much as to sexual orientation.